Gurpreet Singh: Punjabi author Sadhu Binning challenges community's belief in religion

    1 of 1 2 of 1

      Burnaby resident and prominent leftist Punjabi author Sadhu Binning has initiated dialogue on atheism within his community.

      The Punjabi community has mostly captured headlines in the mainstream media for Sikh, Hindu, and Muslim religious festivals, so it is very rare to see someone raising a question on the existence of god within an ethnic group that is perceived as highly orthodox and conservative.

      Binning, an atheist himself, has recently written a Punjabi book, Nastak Baani (Atheistic Verses). Published by Chetna Parkashan in India, it is going to be released at North Delta Recreational Centre on Sunday (September 23). The book launch will include a discussion on the existence of god, with some religious and atheist scholars will speaking.

      Nastak Baani is a collection of quotations from various world-renowned atheists, philosophers, and thinkers who've questioned the concept of religion. It's dedicated to Bhagat Singh, a towering leftist revolutionary of India, who was hanged for killing a British police officer in 1931.

      Bhagat Singh died as an agnostic and had written a powerful essay "Why I am an atheist?" a year before his hanging.

      Binning has spoken lucidly about atheism on Punjabi radio and TV stations despite challenges from both die-hard religious fundamentalists and even from moderates holding traditional views. He wants to break a myth about the South Asian community being "too religious".

      "The idea of atheism was never foreign to our community, as nonbelievers existed even in ancient India," according to Binning. He pointed out that people like Buddha had also questioned the existence of the so-called almighty.

      Besides, some prominent thinkers and reformists, including Periyar and Abraham Kovoor, became guiding light for the atheists and rationalists in India. Periyar launched a "selfrespect movement" after experiencing continued oppression of Dalits or the "untouchables" by Hindu priests.

      Kovoor, who was born in a Christian family, denounced everything he considered superstitious and unscientific. He documented cases of people who were duped by the "godmen" and "ghost busters’". His written work inspired the followers of the rationalist movement in India.

      Incidentally, the birth anniversaries of Periyar and Bhagat Singh and Kovoor’s death anniversary fall this month.

      In the past, Binning wrote a poem appreciating Vancouverites after a survey revealed that a significant number of people in the city are nonreligious. His short stories also give an idea about his secular views toward life and politics.

      As an editor of the Punjabi magazine Watan, he has written extensively on this subject and has often questioned the relevance of promoting too much religion on the public airwaves and also in politics.

      As a linguistic activist who has worked hard to promote Punjabi language in public schools, he has been conscious not to mix the language with religion, a tendency that is quite common among the local Sikh leaders. He believes that the Punjabi language does not belong to the Sikhs alone as it is spoken by other communities too.

      Binning is also staunchly opposed to casteism. Though he is from a dominant Jat (Peasant) Sikh community, his daughter is married to a Hindu. He has brought up his children as atheists and often they and his wife accompany him to rallies and protests against racism and wars.

      Comments

      6 Comments

      prenup

      Sep 22, 2012 at 7:11pm

      almost half of canadians believe the earth was created by god in 6 days 2 thousand years ago *face palm*. How do they explain dinosaurs?

      Serious with 21 major religions in the world ALL with different beliefs how can you really believe one is real/right and another is not. When you step back and look at it without biased its actually sad to see people follow a religion especially when so much pain, suffer, death, abuse and guilt is tied to them.

      Martin Dunphy

      Sep 22, 2012 at 7:28pm

      prenup:

      I agree with virtually everything you said here.

      But for someone who equates organized religion with "pain, suffer(ing), death, abuse and guilt", how do you square that with the fact that elsewhere on this site you called poor people "social parasites"?

      ringo

      Sep 23, 2012 at 7:14am

      Wonderful article! Can't wait to hear more.

      prenup

      Sep 23, 2012 at 7:45am

      Martin,
      I didnt call poor people "social parasites", i called people who feel they are entitled to something they didnt work for "social parasites". By sheer definition I think the term I used is fair and accurate.

      I was poor when i started in life, and my father was poor when he came to this country from europe. I, like my father and many other people who came from nothing decided to work and contribute to society rather then have even the slightest notion of entitlement, or the feeling like somehow someone else, or the government owed me something. I never felt I deserved housing I couldn't afford, or any other "free lunch". If I couldnt afford to live downtown in the most expensive city in north america (which I couldnt at the time) i lived in a basement suit, until I could.

      Poor people are not social parasites, but people who DEMAND social housing or any other hand out from the government funded by people who get up and work hard every day are social parasites.

      There is such a small percentage of people who cant actually contribute in some way. Those people we need to take care of, but the rest need to buck up, contribute and only buy and live where they can afford. It doesnt matter how much you give people like that because they will always feel like they deserve me. Whats next entitlement to cars? How about whistler lifter tickets?

      We (city/government) should go into debt enabling a sense of entitlement in people who simple don't want to contribute or want more then they can afford. In the example where I used the term "social parasites" I was commenting about people living in social housing at olympic village. Personally, I have a fundamental issue with providing social housing on prime water front property in downtown vancouver (most expensive place in north america). I have a problem with our city going into debt to provide it, and I have a problem with the type of person that would even accept it. Yet there are people who actually feel they are OWED it simpley for being alive. Personally I would NEVER accept something like that. I would be too embarrassed.

      See the difference?

      Alon

      Sep 24, 2012 at 3:14pm

      "Why I am an atheist?" - why the question mark, editor? Why is a statement not a question here.

      Aakash Pratap

      Sep 25, 2012 at 6:47pm

      Wonderful article..good one